We’ve been on Substack for 2 years now, and a lot of what we believed at the start turned out to be wrong.
Recently, a business coach about to join the platform asked us what we wish we’d known 2 years ago. Here are the 5 answers, the things we’d tell our day-one selves, so you can skip straight past the mistakes most beginners make on the platform.
1. Substack is not a writing platform, it’s a relationship platform
When we joined, we thought Substack was about great writing. We’d come from platforms where long-form writing was the whole game, so we assumed we’d have to become excellent writers to make it here.
That was wrong. If you want to build an audience here, free or paid, the skill that matters most isn’t writing. It’s relationship building. Writing is just the tool that opens the door. Notes especially get people to notice you. But where they actually connect with you is somewhere else: In live streams, in videos, in the messages you send back and forth.
That’s why you don’t have to be a brilliant long-form writer to do well here. Short-form is far more forgiving, built on hooks and templates, and it does the job of getting the right people into the room. Since we started, the platform has added live streaming, podcasts, and video, so there’s more than ever to build those relationships with. If we’d understood that on day one, we’d have approached the whole thing differently.
2. Paid subscribers matter, but not for the reason you think
When we started, we thought the whole point was to rack up as many paid subscribers as possible.
Here’s what changed our minds: Paid subscriptions make up less than 5% of our annual revenue. Everything else- the digital products, courses, coaching, communities, and collaborations- sits on top of that. So paid subscribers aren’t the prize. But they’re still worth chasing, for two reasons that have nothing to do with that 5%.
The first is proof.
Getting to 100 paid subscribers earns you the Bestseller badge, and on Substack that badge is real.
On other platforms you can just buy the checkmark, so it signals nothing. Here, a badge means real people are paying real money, and that pulls others in. It’s the same reason a line out the door makes you want to see what the fuss is about.
The second is signal.
A paid subscriber has raised their hand. When someone pays to subscribe to us, they’re telling us they’re serious about building and growing on Substack, serious enough to put money behind it. That makes them your warmest possible lead. So get to that first bestseller badge to build the trust, then build the real business on top of it.
3. The connection here is unlike anywhere else, which makes it its own category
Our view of what Substack even is kept changing. First it looked like a writing platform. Then a writing platform with social features. Now we’d put it in a category of its own, because of the quality of the connections you can build here.
Think about the older social platforms for a second. They’re crowded with ads, clickbait, and endless reels, and a lot of people are quietly sick of them. Substack is quieter, and it’s built for going deeper. Here’s a test: Message someone you’ve been talking to on Substack, and chances are high they’ll reply. Now try to remember the last genuinely meaningful conversation you had in someone’s Instagram DMs. For most people, it’s been a while.
That depth is the whole reason live streams work so well. Every time we go live and invite people to reach out about something they’re stuck on, someone does, and a real conversation starts. That rarely happens on the platforms people are leaving.
4. Use Substack with a plan for where it actually leads
This one took us the longest to see: Substack works best when it fits into the bigger picture.
When we started, we assumed everyone came here to grow an audience and turn on paid subscriptions.
But after working with a lot of serious entrepreneurs, we’ve learned that the ones who win the biggest treat Substack as a means to something specific.
They know exactly why they’re here: To win members for a community, to land a book deal, to get booked on stages, to find one-on-one coaching clients, to start a mastermind. For a creator or an operator, Substack is one of the best places going to generate real deal flow.
One person we started working with recently came in with exactly that clarity. He didn’t want to grow a list for its own sake; he wanted to shortcut his path to revenue, and within his first month he was closing real business straight out of DM conversations. Not because of a viral post but because he knew what he wanted the platform to do for him.
Those conversations are where a surprising amount of real business happens, and they’re also where most creators freeze. The Substack DM Playbook gives you the templates to start real conversations that go somewhere, so your deal flow doesn’t depend on guessing what to say.
5. Consistency beats brilliance, every time
The last one is the one we’d tattoo on our day-one selves: Consistency beats brilliance.
When we started, every note was a lottery ticket, written in the hope that this would be the one to go viral and change everything. It never really happened. We have notes with thousands of likes, but never one of those explosive, list-doubling viral hits. And still, we grew from zero to over 55,000 subscribers, purely by showing up. More than 400 days in a row, at least one note every single day, often 3 or 4.
That’s the trade most people get the wrong way around.
Going viral is a lottery ticket. Consistency, on the other hand, is building a foundation.
And a foundation attracts the right people: The ones who found you because you kept showing up with something useful, not because a single note happened to blow up. Viral subscribers mostly don’t care about you, the same way readers you pay to acquire tend to convert worse than the ones who arrive organically.
So the person to bet on isn’t the one who posts 50 notes in a single day and then goes quiet for a week. It’s the one who shows up every day for 50 days. Pick a cadence you can actually hold, and hold it.
Those are the 5 reminders to keep in mind: Build relationships over writing, treat paid as proof and signal, go deep where others stay shallow, work with a plan, and let consistency do the heavy lifting.
Every one of them took us the better part of 2 years to learn the slow way.
If you already run a business or a coaching practice and you’d rather not spend your own 2 years figuring Substack out by trial and error, that’s exactly what we built the Substack Accelerator for.
It’s direct coaching from the Write • Build • Scale team, applied to your specific publication, so you skip the guesswork and move straight to what works. It’s application-based, because we only take people we’re confident we can get there.
If that sounds like you, apply here: substackcoaching.com









