49 Comments
User's avatar
Kristi Keller 🇨🇦's avatar

These are all so good. Especially yours, Sinem. I'm passionate about the branding packages I offer because I too, want to feel like I've stepped into a cohesive community space.

Thanks for sharing all these! It was great to read what some of the other "greats" wish they'd done differently!

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Thanks for contributing, Kristi! I have to admit that I also loved putting this together and seeing all those different perspectives! :)

Expand full comment
Melanie Goodman's avatar

This is so valuable in terms of advice and also a delight to read! @derek Hughes’ advice especially resonates with me as I’m an overdeliverer!

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

I'm so glad you enjoyed this, Melanie. Thanks for the lovely feedback! :)

Expand full comment
Mohib Ur Rehman's avatar

So many great advices packed in 1 post -

Also, I have this question, I haven't started the chat system yet...

I am waiting to get to at least 500 subs or to get some loyal fans who engage with me so I can do that.

I have seen people who are starting out, enabling their chats and they get nothing... in response.

Other than that - I have started dming creators to ask for collabs and stuf...

So, am I on the right path?

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Hi Mohib!

Yeah, you can absolutely wait for a certain subscriber number before you activate chat, but just be careful because a subscriber count per se doesn't mean that there will be more interaction. You can also have an active chat with fewer subscribers if there is clear value in them responding.

In the beginning, when you have fewer subscribers and you want an active chat, each message should feel like your subscriber can get something from the engagement. So you could give away free advice or even some free resources in exchange.

Expand full comment
Shelly Roberts's avatar

Thanks everyone for

being so honest, these are really useful tips.

I’m sure I’ll still make some of the same mistakes but will try hard to learn from all of these experiences 🤞🏻

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Oh yeah, just because you get a list like this doesn't mean that you'll be able to avoid all of them. But I hope that it will still help you save some time and effort on the journey. :)

Expand full comment
Carolyn Parker's avatar

Thank you for compiling this real life guide. I’ve been back here for four months and was surprised to read that I’ve managed to side step several of these mistakes quite by accident.. I love connecting with others and writing as myself which has helped, I guess.

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Well, I'm so glad this was useful, Carolyn, and thanks for your lovely comment. Wishing you all the best on this exciting journey! :)

Expand full comment
Genevieve Brock's avatar

Thank you for compiling all these — it helps!

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

I'm so glad this was useful. Thanks for checking out the post! :)

Expand full comment
Amanda Roberts's avatar

My (freshly launched!) newsletter, Come Back Soon, helps to demystify marketing by laying a solid foundation for brand building. Sinem’s words are great inspiration for future posts, as I want to guide building brands without burnout. Would love to hear from any others struggling with this, and what may be helpful — reach out 🩵

Expand full comment
Amanda Roberts's avatar

The submit button is *way* too close to the text 🫣 you can follow along here: https://open.substack.com/pub/alynrob

Expand full comment
Mark Leiren-Young's avatar

Thanks, as always, for sharing ideas like this. The biggie for me was from Claudia Faith/Wander Wealth. I had no idea it was possible to open chat!

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

I'm glad this one resonated with you, Mark!

And yes, chat is definitely an overlooked feature. We're using it heavily at Write • Build • Scale as well! :)

Expand full comment
Jens Stark's avatar

Some great advice in here, by great people! Thanks for putting it all together, Sinem.

I recognise most faces on here, and hello to those I am yet to meet :o)

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Thanks, Jens! I'm so glad this resonated with you, and hope that you found a few new interesting newsletters to subscribe to! :)

Expand full comment
Landon Poburan's avatar

We need to share more stuff like this! I agree, there is far to much before AND after. We can't only share the mistakes when we can pair it with some marketing magic to sell something. Real authenticity and showing people the journey is so important. Thank you for sharing this Sinem

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Thanks for contributing, Landon. It's always great to feature your voice! :)

Expand full comment
Denise Wakeman's avatar

Excellent advice from all. I need to go back to the drawing board on my thumbnail images.

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Thanks, Denise. I'm glad this was useful! :)

Expand full comment
Jarret Sharp's avatar

Cogent, actionable and relevant.

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Glas you enjoyed it, Jarret! :)

Expand full comment
DIAHANN REYES-LANE's avatar

Super helpful. Makes me think I need go to back to notes.

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

I'm glad this resonated, Diahann! :) And yes, Notes is definitely a superpower!

Expand full comment
Marianna Busching's avatar

Good advice! Since I'm fairly new on Substack, I don't know how to use Notes. ? I'll figure it out....or someone will help me. Or do you just click on it? Wow, I hate to sound so ignorant....

Expand full comment
Sinem Günel's avatar

Hi Marianna! Welcome to Substack! :)

I hope you'll enjoy the community here.

You can just start publishing Notes to familiarize yourself. Also, take a look at our Ultimate Guide to Writing Substack Notes. This should help you as well: https://writebuildscale.substack.com/p/the-ultimate-guide-to-writing-substack?utm_source=publication-search

Expand full comment
Kady Ambrose's avatar

I'm just getting started, so these cautionary tales are invaluable. Thanks!

Expand full comment
True to Type with Pollyanna's avatar

Thank you. That was a very thought provoking read.

Expand full comment